I wrote this a while back–before entering my position as Associate Professor of Church History at Bethel Seminary, St. Paul. At that time, the Iraq war was still new news rather than old news. But some news never gets old–that’s church history. And I decided to offer the best ten reasons I could think of to immerse ourselves in that news:
Top Ten Reasons to Read Christian History
War’s reports deluge us every hour. Why should we read the “old news” of Christian history?
by Chris Armstrong
In a time of war, everything seems to hinge on The Now. But more than ever, it is really a time when we must be in touch with our history—especially, our sacred history.
These are our “Top ten reasons to read Christian history.”
No, this is not a plug for our magazine. You can read Christian history in many other places: Biographies. Histories of Western Civilization (e.g. Jacques Barzun’s From Dawn to Decadence). Novels (e.g. Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin). You can even “read” Christian history on the walls of museums, like the Art Institute of Chicago.
And this, in fact, is …
Because Christian history is everywhere in our culture. No matter what your religious background (or lack thereof), you just can’t understand the modern, Western world—including its wars—unless you know your Christian history!
I was interviewing for an academic position at a small midwestern college, and the committee asked me this: How would you convince our undergraduates to take a course in Christian history? I answered: I would suggest they look around them. So many aspects of American culture come from Christian sources:
Biblical expressions embedded in our language. Christian ethical positions—though dimly remembered and now honored most often in the breach. Assumptions about who human beings are and what we’re doing on this planet—although again, fragmented and unmoored from the theology that once anchored them. Musical styles—even rock’n’roll owes much to slave spirituals and gospel “shouts.”
There’s more. Holidays—Easter, Christmas, even Halloween may all include “pagan” elements, but their frame of reference was always thoroughly Christian. Oh, and let’s not forget St. Patrick’s Day! Art—stroll through almost any Western art exhibit and just try to avoid Christian references, explicit and implicit. Science—I won’t repeat the list of “Christian fathers of the scientific revolution”—see the archive of articles from our issue 76, online. …
If you live in America, or anywhere in the West, your whole environment is soaked in “leftover Christianity.”
Because it liberates you from the tyranny of the present—and of the recent past. The ever-quotable C. S. Lewis put it like this:
“I don’t think we need fear that the study of a day and period, however prolonged, however sympathetic, need be an indulgence in nostalgia or an enslavement to the past. In the individual life as the psychologists have taught us, it’s not the remembered past, it’s the forgotten past that enslaves us. And I think that’s true of society. … I think no class of men are less enslaved to the past than historians. It is the unhistorical who are usually without knowing it enslaved to a very recent past.” (From a radio adaptation of Lewis’s inaugural lecture as Professor of Medieval and Renaissance Literature given at Cambridge on Nov. 29, 1954; see issue 7: C. S. Lewis.)
During wartime, Lewis sharpened the point. He compared the reader of history to the man who has lived in many places. This man “is not likely to be deceived by the local errors of his native village; the scholar has lived in many times and is therefore in some degree immune from the great cataract of nonsense that pours from the press and the microphone of his own age.” (“Learning in War-Time,” in The Weight of Glory.)
Because life is too short to learn by experience. To echo Lewis’s words that we’ve just heard, “the scholar has lived in many times.” What a rich way to grow in wisdom! Though experience can be the best teacher for some things, for others it does not take us far at all.
Job’s friend, Bildad the Shuhite, had it right (for once): “Ask the former generations and find out what their fathers learned, for we were born only yesterday and know nothing, and our days on earth are but a shadow. Will they not instruct you and tell you? Will they not bring forth words from their understanding?” (Job 8:8-10).
Because whatever question is on your mind, someone smarter than you has already seen it clearer, thought about it longer, and expressed it better. Why reinvent the wheel? Also falling under this heading: There are no new heresies—only old ones in new clothes. And again, they’ve all been answered with more wisdom and erudition than we’ll ever be able to muster.
Because the deeper our roots, the higher we grow. Believers are all part of a “Dead Christians Society.” We have far more brothers and sisters in the faith who are no longer around than we do contemporary saints. Lets get to know them. And while we slog it out on earth as members of the Church Militant, the Church Triumphant is pulling for us from heaven.
What a shame to lose a sense of the communion of saints—the “cloud of witnesses” urging us to go on. The heroism, tears, toil, and triumphs of “Dead Christians” can inspire the living.
“Exhibit A” is surely the Martyrs. Blaise Pascal put it like this: “The example of the deaths of Christian martyrs move us, for they are our members, having a common bond with them, so that their devotion inspires us not only by their example, but because we should have the same [qualities].”
Because reading Christian history is a great way to meet fascinating people and hear dramatic, colorful stories. History is all about people. Memorable people. As Ralph Waldo Emerson once put it, “There is properly no history, only biography.” And Thomas Carlyle added, “Biography is the most universally pleasant and profitable of all reading.” Those Victorians had it right—and nothing sizzles like the stories of the saints!
Because reading Christian history helps root out prejudice and foster sympathy and humility. It’s so easy to think “The Church ‘R’ Us.” It ain’t. Most Christian believers look—and have looked, in past centuries—very different than we do. They’ve had different questions, different assumptions, different “lifestyles,” different approaches to the Christian life, different strategies for evangelism, teaching, preaching, sacramental life, social action. …
From the little we may have heard about some of those differences, we’ve probably already put some of our brothers and sisters in a box marked: “Weird.” But in the words of historian Jacques Barzun, reading history “tempers absolute partisanship by showing how few monsters of error there have been.” The more we read about other Christians, the more we get to walk in their shoes and gain respect for their approaches to the faith.
That’s a good thing, because the church today is a body with a wide (and sometimes wild!) variety of members. Knowing more about the past, we gain insight into the practices and problems of other Christians in the present. We may become less critical of others—and even more aware of our own shortcomings and limited perspectives.
Because reading Christian history shows us how we got where we are today. Where did all those denominations come from? How did the distinctive beliefs and practices of my own church develop? What’s the big deal over Calvinism and Arminianism?
Because … well, if #8 depresses you by reminding you of the disunity and dysfunction of the church, then consider this reason, too: We need to read Christian history to remind us of our mission. although we live in “the world” (Augustine called it the City of Man), we are “citizens of another place” (the City of God). We have a mission strange to many of those around us, a mandate to be “in this world but not of it.”
We all are members of local church bodies (or, as my friend Allan Poole likes to say, “outposts of the Kingdom”). Wherever we worship, when we step out of the church doors we still need to “be the church”—salt, light, Different. A powerful way to prepare ourselves for that mission is to read how Christians of the past have sowed the Gospel into their cultures.
Lutheran theologian Joseph Sittler puts it like this. The church, through studying its history, “looks inside herself,” into her own “nature and mission.” When she does this, “she is less likely to take her cues from the business community, the corporation, or the market place” (see Reason #2).
Like the wine at the Cana wedding feast, the best reason has been saved for last: We should read Christian history because Christianity is a historical religion, based on a historical person and the words of two “Testaments” full of historical accounts.
Nineteenth-century liberal theologians liked to talk about the “essence of Christianity”—usually little more than “the Fatherhood of God and the brotherhood of man”—that needed to be extricated from the centuries of errant doctrines and practices of a church that never seemed to get it right. (The problem with this approach, as a wit once observed, is that those nineteenth-century liberals, when they read Christian history, looked down the well of 19 centuries and saw their own faces at the bottom.) But there is no “essence” that is not clothed in history. Christianity is all about the Incarnation of God’s second person as a first-century Jew from Nazareth.
And naturally, then, the New Testament is no philosophical book of abstract teachings. It is a narrative of a life, a sacrifice, a resurrection—played out on the stage of history. And the Book of Acts and the Letters, following the model of the Old Testament’s “historic” books, just picks up the story from Easter. When you read Christian history, you’re paging through the 29th chapter of Acts.
* * *
So next time you’re tempted to tune in for the 200th update on the war in Iraq, think about a few of these reasons, or fill in your own. Then start reading Christian history—or should I say, biography? The “cloud of witnesses” awaits.
Chris, how wonderful for me to find your blog. Your top ten lists are helpful and persuasive. Keep up the good work – too many blogs do not introduce readers to their field – they just right for their colleagues.
Thanks for the kind words, Russ. Good to connect with you on Facebook. May God bless you in your vocational discernment process.