Tag Archives: violence

Violence in Christian history: Proof against the faith? David Bentley Hart speaks


David Bentley Hart is a smart fellow, conversant in philosophy, history, literature, & the arts, who will soon (a little bird tells me) be writing a comprehensive, textbook-type history of the church. Here he is being interviewed about the claim often made by atheists, including the so-called “new atheists,” that the violence evident in Christian history can be used as evidence that Christianity as a whole is a false system of belief, and indeed that there is no God.

Would-be Times Square bomber Faisal Shahzad and America’s “other 9/11” both remind us: Preachers’ words can kill.


Turns out Faisal Shahzad, the would-be bomber of Times Square, was inspired by the teachings of a radical imam, Anwar al-Awlaki, who had also communicated with suspected Fort Hood shooter Maj. Nidal Hasan before he killed 13 people. For me, the most the chilling passage in the WSJ article linked above is this: “Officials said Mr. Shahzad told his interrogators that he read Mr. Awlaki’s English-language writings calling for holy war against Western targets and was moved to action, at least in part, by the cleric’s exhortations.”

Upon reading this, my mind was immediately turned back to an article I researched and wrote on Sept. 11, 2003, about the “other 9/11” in American history–the fateful Sept. 11th on which the preaching of a well-known American religious leader bore similarly violent fruit, resulting in the massacre of 120 American citizens:

Christian History Corner: Learning From the Other 9/11

“Words kill. So teachers, watch what you say”
Chris Armstrong

“It’s getting uncommonly easy to kill people in large numbers,” wrote the Christian scholar, novelist, and lay theologian Dorothy L. Sayers in her novel Gaudy Night. “And the first thing a principle does—if it really is a principle—is to kill somebody.”

I write this as midnight approaches and the calendar flips to the new Day of Infamy. I am thinking, as are many others, of where I was and what I felt on September 11, 2001, when I first heard that airplanes had struck the World Trade Center’s towers.

I was in the basement of the Duke Divinity School’s library, attending to my duties as copy editor of Church History, the journal of the American Society for Church History. Adam Zele, the book review editor, hung up the telephone, his face pale. Continue reading

Crusades and Inquisition: Part of a pattern of Christian violence?


Following up on my recent book note about a current bestseller on the Crusades, here are some further thoughts on that horrible episode of Christian history, as well as that other horrible episode, the Inquisition(s), from a 2003 article triggered by the capture of abortion clinic (and Olympics) bomber Eric Rudolph.

I’ve also added, at the end of this piece, a note by Ted Olsen on how the Inquisition, though atrocious, was not the wholesale bloodbath portrayed in modern anti-Christian rhetoric:

Did Eric Rudolph Act in a “Tradition of Christian Terror”?
A historian considers the evidence of the Crusades and the Inquisition.
Chris Armstrong

The specter of the “Christian terrorist” presented by the recent capture of accused bomber Eric Rudolph has raised again the old charge of the skeptic: “Why should we be surprised when Christians kill people? They’ve always done so. Church history itself is the best advertisement against the church.”

Christianity’s opponents love to use church-historical examples to “prove” that violence is inherent to the Christian church. The favorites are the Crusades and the Inquisitions. The critics ask: Don’t such violent blots on the church prove Christians have never followed their Lord’s loving, non-violent lead and obeyed the Commandment “Thou shalt not kill”? Continue reading